Report: Ohio nurse didn't realize she took kidney

A nurse who accidentally disposed of a living donor's kidney during a transplant said she didn't realize it was in chilled, protective slush that she removed from an operating room, took down a hall to a dirty utility room and "flushed down a hopper," according to a report released by health officials on Monday.

The nurse said she had been on a break when a surgeon told everyone the kidney had been put in the sterile, semi-frozen solution. That detail was in a review by the state for the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and obtained by The Associated Press through a records request. The transplant was Aug. 10 at the University of Toledo Medical Center.

Hospital administrative staff members interviewed on Aug. 21 hadn't determined how the nurse took the 13-gallon bag of slush, meant to extend the kidney's viability, past several members of the medical staff without them noticing a problem, the report said.

It said poor oversight and communication and insufficient policies were factors in the kidney's disposal, which prompted the voluntary, temporary suspension of the hospital's living-donor kidney transplant program and led to reviews by health officials and a consulting surgeon hired by the hospital.

The hospital, in northwest Ohio about 135 miles north of Columbus, "failed to provide adequate supervision and communication resulting in a donor's kidney being carried out of the operating room, down a hall, into a dirty utility room, and flushed down a hopper," the report stated.

The hospital has since enacted clearer policies to clarify communication between nurses who fill in for one another and to make sure nothing is removed from an operating room until the patient has been moved from it, the report said.

The surveyors determined the hospital wasn't in compliance with CMS conditions of participation for transplant and surgical services. CMS will authorize a full review of the conditions of participation for the hospital, and, if it's found out of compliance, it could be terminated from the Medicare program, CMS spokeswoman Elizabeth Surgener said in an email.

The hospital, which says it offers specialty care in areas including cardiology, cancer, surgery and kidney transplantation, also may submit a plan of correction.

A spokesman said he had no comment to provide from the hospital Monday.

The hospital hasn't said what happened to the intended kidney recipient, who was supposed to receive an organ donated by her brother. The intended recipient and her brother were released from the hospital, which didn't identify them and said it couldn't say whether she received a different kidney.

Hospital officials apologized and hired a Texas surgeon to evaluate their transplant procedures but have not released the results of that evaluation.

The medical center suspended two nurses after the incident; one was later fired, and the other resigned, the hospital said. A surgeon was stripped of his title as director of some surgical services, and a surgical services administrator put on paid leave has resumed work.

The hospital also notified 975 patients and potential organ donors and recipients that they might need to make other arrangements for services typically provided through the program under review.

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4

There is no reason anyone else should not get the medical procedures they need just because of one accident. The lesson was learned when the mistake was made, there is no need to punish everyone or anyone any longer.

    Reply#89 - Thu Sep 27, 2012 1:16 AM EDT

    Just wow!

      Reply#90 - Thu Sep 27, 2012 3:30 AM EDT

      The whole reason they were there in the first place was tossed down the hopper? Was this nurse not briefed on what the procedure was for ahead of time?

      Boggles the mind.

        Reply#91 - Thu Sep 27, 2012 7:19 AM EDT

        The public truly has little knowledge of the level of politics and the working conditions that RNs must endure. The issue of medical errors is in the news frequently yet obvious unsafe practices are never addressed. Many hospitals in New York state make their staff rotate shifts as standard practice. It is easier for the hospital to pull their nurses to whatever shift they need filled rather than give them a set shift. They will make the claim that this happens in a structured manner- i.e., a set amount of time on night shift then day shift but in reality there are nurses that work night shift, sleep the next day then work day shift. Needless to say their bodies cannot adjust to this unhealthy unsafe practice. These are not factory workers whose clouded and fatigued judgement causes a production error. Why this is permitted is a mystery but nursing administrators will defend it and deny that it is a patient safety issue. I personally do not want a nurse caring for my family member who is 'functioning' on a disrupted sleep pattern or who is working their fifth, sixth, or seventh twelve hour shift in a row.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#92 - Thu Sep 27, 2012 9:37 AM EDT

        I am an RN. The most important thing an RN can do is use Critical Thinking. I see this lacking greatly in MOST nurses not trained in the United States. Other countries teach just do the task, procedure, give the med. US teaches think, why, what, how, does this make sense. My guess would be that this nurse was trained outside the United States.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#93 - Thu Sep 27, 2012 11:29 AM EDT

        Why so eager to dispose of the tissue during the procedure. It couldn't wait till the stitches were in?

          Reply#94 - Sun Sep 30, 2012 5:26 PM EDT

          Wow, 1 person made the mistake & a program closed, people fired etc. Does not make sense. A label on something that important, should have been used, or put the kidney in a safe place. Nurses are constantly cleaning & preparing. This unfortunate mistake could have happened to anyone. A simple label could have prevented the whole thing. When you have so much staff coming & going not everyone gets the communication.

            Reply#95 - Mon Oct 1, 2012 5:00 PM EDT
            Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.