West Nile outbreak stresses lab testing limits, delays diagnosis

LM Otero / AP file

Mosquitoes were sorted at a laboratory in Dallas County, Texas, as an outbreak of West Nile virus mounted last month.

A spike in West Nile virus infections in the U.S. this summer has strained the nation’s laboratory testing capabilities, creating brief shortages of diagnostic test kits and forcing lab staffers in some states to work extra shifts or rely on temporary hires for help.

The outbreak has surged to at least 2,636 cases and has caused 118 deaths, officials with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Wednesday. Of those, 1,405 cases have been serious neuroinvasive disease infections. That ranks it as the most serious outbreak to date since the mosquito-borne virus was detected in the U.S. in 1999., said Dr. Lyle Petersen, director of the CDC's division of vector-borne infectious diseases.

The epidemic also has highlighted gaps in the system used to track and treat illness outbreaks and epidemics, experts say.

“West Nile just brought it back to us,” said Irina Lutinger, senior administrative director for NYU’s Langone Medical Center and a spokeswoman for the American Society for Clinical Pathology. “We only have limited resources to accommodate such an increase.”

In Oklahoma, two primary in-state reference labs had to halt West Nile tests briefly in late August because they ran out of kits, even as the nation’s leading commercial labs had to suspend or delay tests -- or prioritize samples of those suspected of having the most serious illnesses.

“We had a complete pause in testing,” said Kristy Bradley, the Oklahoma state health epidemiologist. “What I was surprised about is that it reached such a critical level before we were aware of it.”

In Texas, where latest figures show West Nile has sickened at least 1,127 people and caused 50 deaths, state public health laboratory staffers have been working extended shifts, including weekends and holidays. Four temporary lab workers were recently hired to help meet demand, said Grace Kubin, director of the Texas Department of State Health Services laboratory.

Neither health officials nor the makers of the tests would release figures about the number of West Nile tests performed this year compared with previous years.

However, everyone agrees that it is way up.

“I can say it’s probably doubled, easily, for the human testing,” said Kubin. Tests of environmental samples from mosquito pools, for instance, have tripled over normal levels, she said.

West Nile virus is a mosquito-borne disease that has been detected this year in 48 states. Most infected people, about 80 percent, never know they have it. About 20 percent, however, develop West Nile fever, which causes flu-like symptoms, including headache, fever, body aches, swollen lymph glands and, sometimes, a rash. Less than 1 percent of infected people develop severe West Nile disease, the neuroinvasive form of the infection, which can lead to meningitis or encephalitis. 

The outbreak is still short of the worst-ever West Nile season in the U.S.; in 2003, there were 9,862 total cases, 2,866 neuroinvasive cases and 264 deaths. But those figures included artificially high numbers inflated by one state's posting of cases of West Nile fever, Petersen said. This year's high number of neuroinvasive cases for the second week of September make it the worst outbreak to date, Petersen said.

However, he said that West Nile cases typically peak in mid-to-late August and that officials believe the outbreak is beginning to wane, especially as cooler weather approaches.

"Based on historical data, we’ve turned the corner on the epidemic," Petersen said. "We’re hopeful that the worst of the outbreak is behind us."

The shortage of testing kits manufactured by the nation’s leading provider, Focus Diagnostics, was caused largely because unanticipated demand outstripped supply, said Wendy Bost, spokeswoman for Quest Diagnostics, the commercial lab that runs Focus. The backlog is adding as much as three to five days to the turnaround times on West Nile virus tests, Bost told NBC News.

“The magnitude of the current outbreak of West Nile virus in the United States was not widely anticipated by public health authorities,” Bost said.

But Food and Drug Administration officials said they became concerned about a potential shortage of test kits in late August, when they contacted Focus and found the company had backorders of the West Nile virus IgM antibody test kit. That test determines whether a patient is acutely infected with the West Nile virus.

At the urging of the FDA, the CDC and other health officials, Focus ramped up production of the test kits, which can take weeks to produce and have a shelf life of about 24 months.

That helped avert a larger problem, said Kelly Wroblewski, director of infectious disease programs for the Association of Public Health Laboratories.

“At this point, there isn’t really a shortage,” she said. “In most cases, if stoppage had to happen at all, it only had to happen for a maximum of two days. I think it’s a supply and demand situation like anything else.”

In some states hit hard with West Nile, such as South Dakota and Mississippi, officials said they’ve managed to keep up with testing demand.

“We are not falling behind,” said Lon Kightlinger, the South Dakota state epidemiologist.

In Texas, lab director Kubin said she actually heard early that there might be a shortage of test kits and asked her supervisor to stock up.

Because there's no treatment for West Nile virus in humans, no one was denied care because of the lab test delays. With a different virus, however, any lag in testing could have slowed vital treatment, experts said. 

However, the shortage of lab techs to handle West Nile demand highlights a larger issue, said Lutinger, of the ASCP.

In the U.S., about 11,000 new lab workers are needed every year, but only 6,000 are graduating, Lutinger said. As older workers, called laboratorians, retire and fewer newcomers fill the slots, the vacancy rates in the field are growing.

“By 2018, if more students and second careerists are not recruited to become laboratory professionals, the shortage could be as high as 18 percent in areas such as blood banking,” she said.

About 70 percent of doctors’ decisions are based on the outcome of lab analysis, Lutinger noted.

“At a time of critical importance of providing diagnosis and test results to arm these physicians with these results, we frequently face the challenges of being unable to have trained technologists,” she said.

Too few lab workers may mean delays in diagnosis and treatment of disease – and slower response to large-scale public health crises, such as the 2009 H1N1 flu pandemic.

“It certainly has the potential to hinder our ability to respond in emergencies,” said Wroblewski.

Part of the problem may be that it’s a low-profile profession, so not many students consider becoming laboratory technologists, she said. The starting pay for public labs can be moderate, about $40,000 to $50,000 a year, and commercial labs may steal workers away by paying up to 50 percent more.

That presents a challenge for public health labs, as the current West Nile outbreak demonstrates.

“If the projections of the ASCP are correct and this continues to be a problem for the next several years, the situation of public health labs being in a good position could change,” Wroblewski said.

Related stories: 


With 66 deaths, this could be the worst year in the U.S. for the West Nile Virus, which was introduced to the country in 1999. NBC's Nancy Snyderman reports.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Discuss this post

Sounds like a great business opportunity for job creation. Get moving!

    Reply#1 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 9:30 AM EDT

    The GOP keeps leading and proposing to cut ALL science paid for with tax dollars. This way, the rich pay for a PRIVATE diagnosis and the poor, they just die because they are on their own.

    • 3 votes
    #1.1 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 1:31 PM EDT
    Reply

    so where are the test kits manufactured at ? sounds like opportunity and jobs but the author seems to make it a case of over worked lab techs ? Its for the good of the country get on with it .

    • 2 votes
    Reply#2 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 10:52 AM EDT

    If there is a shortage of lab techs, why don't they lower the cost of college and give more people an opportunity for training in the lab tech field, along with other fields. I am currently in college, getting my degree in Health Information Technologies. If not for the Federal Pell Grant and a scholarship I won, I would still be sitting at home, in limbo, with no working skills and no chance at a job. Years ago, you could walk into a place, get the job, that included on the job training. Not anymore. I am in my 50's and I advise anyone to get a college education, no matter your age. The job market is brutal and if you don't have the qualifications, you are screwed.

    • 4 votes
    Reply#3 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 11:55 AM EDT

    Ah, mosquitoes. Nature's dirty syringes.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 12:08 PM EDT

    I tested positive for WNF and can say it sucked. The headaches, and sore throbbing muscles/joints was worse than the 101.7 fever I had along with it. Thankfully it seems to have run it's ocurse and I am feeling worlds better. Still have no idea when or where I may have been bit which is scary.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#5 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 12:19 PM EDT

    My brother had West Nile several years ago and survived.... it was very scary..he still has all sorts of medical problems from it and today his wife is in hospital with fever and tests have ruled something is wrong.. but cant find the source.. whatever it is its affecting her brain and her heart.. I pray they will find something soon to stop this deadly virus...

    • 2 votes
    Reply#6 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 12:22 PM EDT

    I had westnile in 2003. Took weeks to verify it and even then they weren't sure. Im still effected by it today. Hope they can get a hand on this. One note, spray yourself and your kids. This stuff is bad stuff!

    • 1 vote
    Reply#7 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 12:33 PM EDT

    I can remember the family laughing at my Uncle Curt for paving his small lot, making a huge driveway & deck. He said he did it to keep the bugs away.......now who's laughing.

    • 2 votes
    Reply#8 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 12:50 PM EDT

    in 1999 they said a vaccination in 7 years(CDC) got a horse vaccination in 3 yrs and I keep wondering when when when are they really working on a human vaccination or not?? We have had 1 death in our family already and it involved coma,paralization, 7 months ICU, 2 yrs laying in a nursing home then only able to answer our ?`s by blinking a eyelid then of course death Hello CDC can u hear???????????

    • 2 votes
    Reply#9 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 1:29 PM EDT

    If there is such a shortage of med techs, why not lower the requirement from a four year college degree to a two-year degree? Much of the work in this field is done by automation, and the requirements for B.S. & licensure weren't always in the field.

    • 2 votes
    Reply#10 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 1:34 PM EDT

    The reason for the shortage of laboratory technologists is there aren't that many programs. The number of programs has shrank in the past decade due to funding issues, lack of interest from students, and many other things. I am one and most of us feel like we're at the bottom of the hierarchy in the healthcare system. We take heat from the doctors and nurses, when most of the time it wasn't our fault. This coupled with lack of job satisfaction has lead to many people I work with to go back to school to become MDs, DODs, PAs, and Nurses.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#11 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 2:50 PM EDT

    Those labs will be even more strained under the Ryan/Romney budget plan...this is one of those cuts so we can make more weapons to kill people with...

    • 1 vote
    Reply#12 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 2:51 PM EDT

    yay more death.

      #12.1 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 3:14 PM EDT
      Reply

      I find it disheartening that members of our own profession are suggesting lowering the requirements for lab staff. There is a great deal of theory and critical thinking ability that go into good medical laboratory science and the field is changing quickly. We need a higher level of education, not a lower one (not to mention the respect factor that we all complain so much about--think we'll get more respect by lowering our education requirements??) I have worked with some fabulous MLTs, but think we have the opportunity to strengthen and elevate laboratory medicine with higher education requirements and licensure. Medical laboratory science is an awesome field with tons of opportunity--if you're interested in health care, but like science more than direct patient care, we need you!

        Reply#13 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 7:57 PM EDT

        So earning a Bachelors' degree automatically earns someone more respect? I don't think so.

        I've known my share of college grads who conducted themselves like idiots. I'm not sure why a two year degree that had a comprehensive science education would be such a bad thing, especially if one is talking adult lab aides who want to move higher & may not have the time to commit to a four year program. In some countries, medical technology is a vocational technical course of study in the high schools, and they laugh themselves silly at the requirement of a bachelors' degree for the pay earned in this country.

          #13.1 - Thu Sep 13, 2012 3:33 PM EDT
          Reply

          The problem doesn't lie with training and experience, it relies on having the ability to test for the disease. It is also a rare and unexpected symptom classification. Only about .000003% of the population is experiencing the symptoms of WNV and its variations can be numerous. I feel for the practitioners of medicine to diagnose the problem. Let alone having the inability to test for it. As far as the job prospects for MLT's: I feel the need for more MLT's is needed. The pay sucks (unless you have been doing it for a long time), not much reward, but if you don't like the patient interation and still want to be part of a medical team this job is right down your alley. As far as education goes, The more you know the better the pay. I do agree that our education system needs to be revamped concerning some of the areas of medicine that require a four year or more degree. But that is all together another subject.

            Reply#14 - Wed Sep 12, 2012 11:23 PM EDT
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.