German doctors apologize for Holocaust horrors

The German Medical Association has issued a remarkably blunt and straightforward apology, more than six decades after the end of World War II, for the role it played during the Holocaust in the mass murder, sterilization and barbaric medical experiments done on Jews and many other groups.

The apology, made Wednesday at the Bundesärztekammer (German Medical Association) meeting in Nuremberg, makes no excuses.

Unanimously adopted by the delegates of the Physician's Congress, the declaration says that contrary to popular belief doctors were not forced by political authorities to kill and experiment on prisoners but rather engaged in the Holocaust as leaders and enthusiastic Nazi supporters.

The apology notes that “outstanding representatives of renowned academic medical and research institutions were involved” in organizing and carrying out the mass extermination of millions.

In the statement, the German doctors said they “remember the living and deceased victims and their descendants and ask them for forgiveness."

I don’t know if forgiveness will be forthcoming. 

But in the history of apologies for crimes and abuses carried out in the name of medicine this is the most important ever made. It does nothing to soften the horror of the Holocaust but it both ascribes responsibility where it belongs and ends any further efforts to deny or obfuscate what actually happened.

My father was there to see some of it. On April 29, 1945, Army Sgt. Sidney D. Caplan was among the troops that liberated the Dachau death camp outside of Munich Germany. By the end of the war, nearly 6 million Jews and countless others had been killed.

The Nuremberg trials that followed the defeat of the German Reich showed the intimate role that medicine had played in the Holocaust. Many know about Dr. Josef Mengele's gruesome experiments, but now the actions of mainstream medicine have been acknowledged.

German medicine as field has remained silent about it all these decades – until today.

The world must still grapple with the Holocaust as genocide carried out in the name of science and medicine. But it no longer needs to try and push those involved in German medicine to speak about their role. They have done so and they deserve full credit for it.

The world should acknowledge that medicine has finally stared its worst crimes directly in the face and shuddered.

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 5 6

Japanese will never do that until they get ten more nuke and 20 more tsunamis.

  • 1 vote
Reply#55 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:15 AM EDT

It is indeed about time -- but it is too little and much too late. Doctors, regardless of their political affiliation or being under a dictatorship, ought to adhere to higher standards than others, particularly "First do no harm". I've never really understood how any medical doctors, even under the Nazi regime, could have perpetrated the horrors of the "medical experiments: in the death camps; participated in the classification of Jews, Roma, and others as "non-human"; espoused, or agreed with, half-baked pseudo-scientific explanations of the "superiority" or "inferirority" of races; performed eugenics against the disabled or mentally ill; or allowed the mistreatment, starvation, and disease among the prisoners of the camps. The only explanation I've heard as to why German doctors went along with all the above is that they rationalized their actions. Contrary to what many believe, many Nazis and their medical establishments were not insane or irrational slaughterers; instead, they were hyper-rational butchers who believed they had cogent, scientifically-backed reasons to justify their actions. And yet the Nazis also eliminated intellectuals, philosophers, and academians who were intelligent enough to oppose them or even replace them; given that the Nazi leaders, for the most part, were ignorant, uneducated thugs who knew just enough to be be dangerous. Bad as they were, however, the medical practioners (or malpractioners) under their authority were worse, because they should have known better. Persons of integrity should have refused immoral orders and commands, even at the risk of their own lives.

    Reply#56 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:15 AM EDT

    Its all made up....Fiction.

    • 1 vote
    #56.1 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:30 AM EDT
    Reply

    Mengele may have been more of a monster than Hitler.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#57 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:18 AM EDT

    You know, Hitler was right. The Third Reich will live on for 1,000 years; just not in the way he intended. It will probably take that long for people to come to terms with what actually happened.

      Reply#58 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:20 AM EDT

      This is as meaningful as Bill Clinton apologising for FDR's treratment of Japanese Americans during WWII. I can't wait for Barack Obama to apologise for George Washington owning slaves.

        Reply#59 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:21 AM EDT

        George stole my pizza and Bill apologize for my stolen pizza. I don't get what that mean.

          #59.1 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:24 AM EDT

          Only Justice brings Peace. You can not sit here and tell me that the generations in America today did not benefit from the slave trade and all the money it made to send your ancestors to college or to help them start a business using money they did not EARN. Or that the Native Americans dying and being killed had nothing to do with us living off their land today!!!

          Yes, there are some apologies in order. I can see why no one wants to apologize, thats an admission of guilt and responsibility. But that's cool. Just keep on pretending that everything you are and everything you have today, we all have, in no way was connected to the FOUNDING of this country. It all happened by magic!!!!

          • 2 votes
          #59.2 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:37 AM EDT
          Reply

          How will this look to all them that refused to admit it ever happened in the first place

            Reply#60 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:22 AM EDT
            sherantsDeleted

            The Germans used to be evil sinister people and now they're not?

              Reply#62 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:29 AM EDT

              Hmmm...

                #62.1 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:36 AM EDT
                Reply

                Great. Now maybe Americans can find the courage to apologize for 200 years of slavery and the slaughter and sytematic destruction of the Native American population. We have issued it for the Japanese for WWII, even to Germany. But there is no acceptance of what was done to people in this Country!!!!

                • 1 vote
                Reply#63 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:29 AM EDT

                Acknowledgement of painful truths about our failings is very rare among human beings.

                Sure, this would have been more meaningful before, but it still occurred in a time span shorter by hundreds of years than the Catholic church apologizing for killing, torture, forced conversions, and expulsions of Jews in the various Inquisitions... which obviously (including the non accountability that followed) served as a visible precedent to the Nazis (as did the massacres in Armenia in the early 20th Century and the Crusades).

                The reason things like this matter so much is that people cling to easy answers and explanations in order to avoid the reality of the situation - which is that it wasn't just a charismatic leader or a perfect storm of events or some particular type of political rhetoric that caused the Holocaust and all of these other acts of genocide. They were all popularly supported and enabled by people who were just like us in most ways.

                Scapegoating of other people and the tendency to believe what we prefer to believe - including that we are somehow special or more deserving or holy than others - are the key ingredients for genocide, every time. The fact that those are more popular than ever shows that, despite decades of self serving blather about WWII, we learned almost nothing from it.

                • 1 vote
                Reply#64 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:29 AM EDT

                When are American drug companies, Pfizer, Endo, Purdue Pharma et al going to apologize for the 400,000 fatal accidental rx poisonings since 1995 in the U.S. and the addictions, ruined families, maimings, drownings, auto accidents, pharmacy shootouts etc. attributable to their poison pills. 40,000 fatal rx poisonings in 2011 alone. Worldwide it shouldn't take Big Pharma more than 15 more years to beat the Nazi's record. Doctors? Croakers.

                  Reply#65 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:38 AM EDT

                  Hopefully, this will, once and for all, shut the mouths of all the world's fools and naysayers who claim the Holocaust never happened! But damn, it would have been a heck of a lot better if this apology had been made several decades ago when the doctors who gleefully took part in these horrors and atrocities, could have been arrested and made to stand before the judges at Nuremberg..

                  Better late then never, I suppose...

                  Now, if only the tobacco and drug companies would be as forthright in admitting how many have died using their products...

                    Reply#66 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:42 AM EDT

                    The article is by a guy with a Jewish name, possibly with links to the Zionista, "terrorism". . . Better hold on to your horses... This could actually be a precursor to the apology for the Palestine and Arab Holocaust... among others.

                    • 1 vote
                    Reply#67 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:43 AM EDT

                    Try and read,which is probably difficult for someone with your limited intellegence , about the area known today as Isreal and its' history.The Jews are not the bad guys in History,its' the Turks first and then the English!The Palestians create their own hell! Remeber what Golda Mire said in the 1960's! "There will always be conflicts between the Jews and Palestians until the Palestians love their children more than they hate Jews"!Reme3ber waht Netanyahu said about a decade ago about the Palestians! "They never miss a chance to miss a chance"! The Palestians have to shuolder a large portion of the blame !No ,i'm no a Jew!

                      #67.1 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:26 AM EDT

                      Wow! insulting and really stupid, incoherent and irrational. Thank god you qualified it by saying you're not a Jew. Good work.

                      • 2 votes
                      #67.2 - Fri May 25, 2012 2:43 AM EDT
                      Reply

                      The world should acknowledge that medicine has finally stared its worst crimes directly in the face and shuddered.

                      Yeah, although the profession's ridiculous over billing has to be a close second.

                      • 2 votes
                      Reply#68 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:49 AM EDT

                      an apology. this apology is to little and way to late.

                        Reply#69 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:54 AM EDT

                        Any of those doctors still alive today?

                        If yes, try in court, convict, and execute.

                        If no, what's the point of this ridiculous apology?

                          Reply#70 - Fri May 25, 2012 12:56 AM EDT

                          One should not forget the corporations of America that willingly and knowingly aided Hitler's war machine and death camps, through their domestic facilities or German branches and subsidiaries. Many American companies were deeply tied to the fascism of Nazi Germany and other fascist countries. Corporate America's anti-Semitism wasn't far from that of Hitler. Money, or should I say profits, was the name of the game and it didn't matter how many innocent people died, how they died or for which reason they died. Corporate America was the arsenal of Nazism. Hitler could not have succeeded without them. Their holy grail was the tempting proposition that several large corporations could take financial control of the world, which is no different than the corporate mindset of today. Many American corporate executives, their representatives and other high profile and influential Americans had meetings with Hitler and/or his minions.

                          Morgan, General Electric, Standard Oil of New Jersey (Rockefellers), DuPont, Brown Brothers Harriman (one partner with the name of Prescott Sheldon Bush), UBC, Ford, General Motors (through its wholly owned Opel division), IBM, Sullivan&Cromwell (Wall Street), Texaco, Chase National Bank (by freezing the assets of Jews), Kodac (used slave laborers from concentration camps), United Steel, Alcoa Aluminum, Chrysler, Dow Chemical, Curtiss-Wright Aviation and IT&T headed the list. Of course, there are more that supported Hitler's Nazis through lesser means, along with other fascist leaders of Europe.

                          Don't believe it? Pull your heads out of the sand and do a little research. You can then repeat after me: Money is God, money is God, money is God. Profits are holy and nothing else matters.

                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#71 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:17 AM EDT

                          You are insane and didn't even touch on the real international criminals who were almost solely responsible for Germany's war machine,the Swiss!

                            #71.1 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:20 AM EDT

                            Deny it if you wish, mas098. You're simply publicly displaying your refusal to research the matter and learn the truth. Now, do you want to know where many of the criminal Japanese doctors and scientists moved to after the same war and who sponsored them? I'm almost certain you'll deny that also.

                            I'm as much an American patriot as the next guy, but I'll be damned if I'll ignore the truth simply because I'm an American citizen.

                            Let me help you; go to a search bar and type "American corporations and individuals who supported and aided Hitler and the fascism of Europe". You can then do a search concerning the criminal doctors and scientists of Japan.

                            • 1 vote
                            #71.2 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:25 AM EDT

                            Read "While Six Million Died: A Chronicle of American Apathy" by Aurthur D. Morse.

                            It is very enlightening.

                              #71.3 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:29 AM EDT

                              I'm not denying anything but so far you have incriminated soome of America's most prominate leaders.You start with American complicity and move effertly over to the Japanese! Somewhere in there is a true story of Swiss fianacing that you should read about and then make your commentss.Without Swiss neutrality and use of their banking system,the Nazis couldn't have built one cannon! They sponsered,financed and egged on the Germans as payoff not to invade Switzerland!Try reading about Mexico,during WW1 and WW2, while you look the Swiss,there is another good story!

                                #71.4 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:32 AM EDT

                                Thank you, Misscreant. I think I will.

                                • 1 vote
                                #71.5 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:34 AM EDT

                                Welcome.

                                Having met a Holocaust survivor from Romania, I was particularly appalled by our refusal to bomb rail lines used to transport Romanian Jews to Auschwitz, because that was not "in our objectives."

                                  #71.6 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:35 AM EDT

                                  "............but so far you have incriminated soome of America's most prominate leaders."

                                  I haven't incriminated anyone. I'm simply stating the facts. Speaking of Swiss financing, let's discuss the role of Wall Street during the period the fascists controlled certain European countries. Oh, you didn't know about that?

                                    #71.7 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:37 AM EDT

                                    Sichuan! I take you name calling as a compliment ,coming from its' source!Learn to read,then you can learn to commit!

                                      #71.8 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:44 AM EDT

                                      "Sichuan! I take you name calling as a compliment ,coming from its' source!Learn to read,then you can learn to commit!

                                      maso98, you really need to explain your post.

                                        #71.9 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:54 AM EDT
                                        Reply

                                        Do you think that the doctors,who today, are performing abortions, will say and mirror actions of these men, in 60 years! I think not!

                                          Reply#72 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:18 AM EDT

                                          Okay . . .

                                          I apologize for my ancestors (they immigrated here during the turn of the century (1895 - 1905), the largest immigration period for people from Europe to the US). They never owned slaves, didn't (to my knowledge) commit any genocide against the native American population, or partake in any inquistions. But, hey - I do apologize. Mea Culpa! (Can I be excused from the "liberal guilt" now?)

                                            Reply#73 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:23 AM EDT

                                            To the German doctors, why are you apologizing now since it has been over 6 decades ago??? You should have apologized that either during or after the Nuremberg trials. My God! What fools to apologize now! For those "doctors" who were working with the Nazi Regime should have been imprisoned for life!

                                              Reply#74 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:27 AM EDT

                                              Seems pretty honest with the usual German bluntness -- albeit so late. Those guys don't hold back when they say things.

                                              Certainly a good example -- compare with the mealy-mouth, wish-washy apologies our politicians make for their blunders.

                                                Reply#75 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:30 AM EDT

                                                Thers a lot of fault to go around for the crimes of the Nazis and their comrades.But all the damage they caused and lives that were lost is an inksopt on page compared to what Stalin did to Russians after the war.And after that,what Mao did to the Chinese.Stalin was known to have repeatly commented that "Russia only needs a hundred million citizens,the rest are expendible!"I tried his best to hit his mark!Communism and socialism were the graveyard of mankind in the 20th centruy.I believe if total,they communist and socialist have killed more people than all wars before them in tthe previous two hundred years!

                                                  Reply#76 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:40 AM EDT

                                                  I have translated many English, German and Dutch medical and para-medical dissertations. If there is no mention of reference source(s), specifically from German research, without a doubt the data originated from German laboratory tests on Jews in prison camps. Not many people know this, but it is a well-kept secret in medical circles !!!

                                                    Reply#77 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:42 AM EDT

                                                    Although alot of people probably disagree, their choice to make a public apology is a big step. I come from a line of jewish/english desecendants, and I appreciate the apology. Time heals ALL wounds.

                                                      Reply#78 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:53 AM EDT

                                                      Decades of silence while the perpetrators lived in comfort is a moral failing of slightly less significance than the original crime.

                                                        Reply#79 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:55 AM EDT

                                                        personally, i'd have to say the things the Japanese did as a whole were MUCH MUCH worse. both were terrible nonetheless but i'd have taken my chances at a German concentration camp before I ever even considered being put in any sort of Japanese camp during ww2

                                                          Reply#80 - Fri May 25, 2012 1:55 AM EDT
                                                          Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 5 6
                                                          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.