Truckloads of medical products, tankers of bulk liquids and cartons of chemicals have been hauled to secure landfills and waste disposal centers as a Wisconsin supplier works to recover from a year-long contamination scandal blamed for illness and death.
By one account, H&P Industries and the Triad Group of Hartland, Wis., had enough potentially tainted medical prep wipes to fill a football field.
The sister firms have either destroyed or reconditioned more than $6 million of suspect products seized by federal regulators last spring, bringing them in compliance with a court order, new government documents show.
The firm’s $4 million penal bond has been canceled and the seized products have been returned to H&P’s jurisdiction for disposal, possible steps toward reopening, according to new Food and Drug Administration documents obtained through an msnbc.com open records request and appeal.
The discarded products included 50 truckloads of finished goods, 13 truckloads of raw chemicals and five bulk tank-trailers of in-process materials, according to Shelly Burgess, an FDA spokeswoman.
"The firm will not be permitted to resume operations until FDA is satisfied that it can do so with full compliance with the decree and the law," Burgess said.
It took H&P Industries three tries to gain FDA approval of a reconditioning plan that outlines an overhaul of manufacturing, monitoring, inspection and reporting procedures to correct problems with contamination and sterilization. Previous plans were not detailed enough to satisfy FDA’s concerns, the documents posted online late Tuesday showed.
“Because of both micro- and cross-contamination concerns, FDA has no [good manufacturing process] assurance and is uncomfortable with introducing any potential risk back into the market,” said Tamara Ely, an FDA compliance officer, according to an account of a November 21, 2011 meeting.
Only unopened, factory-sealed raw chemicals will be allowed to be “reconditioned” so that they’re safe for use either by H&P Industries or by a vendor who agrees to accept returned product, the documents showed. The reconditioning procedure requires sampling, testing and approval to verify that no microbial contamination exists.
Everything else — finished products, in-process products, materials in tanks and drums, raw chemicals, bulk chemicals and other open, used components — was destroyed. The firm is still prohibited from manufacturing drugs or devices, Burgess noted.
H&P’s compliance comes more than a year after FDA officials urged the company to issue the first of several global recalls of alcohol and iodine prep products potentially contaminated with at least two kinds of bacteria because of inadequate manufacturing and sterilization procedures.
FDA officials had known for years about problems with the Wisconsin plant, but had failed to adequately enforce regulations, an msnbc.com investigation found.
The move also comes nearly a year after parents of a 2-year-old Houston boy first filed a lawsuit claiming that contaminated alcohol pads made by H&P Industries were responsible for the bacterial infection that killed their son.
Since then, at least a dozen lawsuits have been filed by patients and their families in several states who claim that tainted prep wipes led to infections, illnesses and, in some cases, deaths.
H&P Industries officials did not respond to msnbc.com requests for comment, but the firm consistently has denied that its products could be directly tied to those events.
Burgess, the FDA spokeswoman, confirmed the number of truckloads of finished medical products, tanker trucks of bulk liquids and containers of chemicals that the company was forced to destroy.
But by another estimate, the volume of returned alcohol and iodine prep products alone would have filled an area “the size of a football field,” according to a lawyer representing the Triad Group.
“There are billions of these pads produced a year, millions in a day, believe it or not, so it is massive what has been returned,” lawyer Alana Bassin told U.S. District Court Judge Lynn Hughes during a July briefing, a court transcript shows.
The medical products have been transferred to secure landfill and destruction sites that operate under regulatory jurisdiction. Some of the material may have to be processed as hazardous waste, the documents noted.
H&P Industries' plans for the future remain unclear. The firm’s 285,000-square-foot plant at 700 W. North Shore Drive , Hartland, Wis., is for sale for $14.2 million, real estate listings show.
Related: Tracking tainted wipes: an msnbc.com special investigation



It must be a heavy blow for the Triad group owners that funded Gov. Walkers run for Wisconsin Governor. What a disgusting bunch of folks that are charged with producing safe wipes for shots and blood work. They produced and sold this crap for years before they were forced to stop making them in a filthy plant! I have asked my physician to avoid purchasing the Triad products EVER again!
Absolutely. They minimized and lied their way through it until the fatalities started happening. I look forward to seeing some major payouts to the families of those killed by their negligence. I also hope that the Management/Ownership faces some criminal liability as well.
Hey, but who needs government oversight, right? Right? The market economy will take care of itself (after a few customers die).
Yea it's worked so well so far. Let's have more incompetence.
That would be a scary place to live where the only way you can determine if a company makes safe products if whether people start dropping dead from them.
The FDA knew about problems with the plant for over a decade and did nothing so you "governement oversight" arguement is without merit.
http://www.jsonline.com/watchdog/watchdogreports/129630443.html?page=1
And Republicans says the government REGULATES too much.
It took the O administration to stop these freaks.
Then how come MSNBC had to go to the lengths it did to get in information?? It took the O administration a year to shut these killers down. Boy, that's really Odummer on the ball.
Yes indeed a mess and too bad companies won't use bar codes to recall such products and you can see my interview in the Milwaukee paper about this problem too. Been over 2 years for me campaigning for this.
http://ducknetweb.blogspot.com/2011/07/recalled-wipes-from-triad-still-out.html
The government DOES regulate too much, but this is not one of the regulations to get rid of.
Can we please stop saying "moving forward"? You sound like a corporate idiot.
Hold On - Why did MSNBC have to go to the lengths it did to get the information it did? What happened to Obama's transparency in government???
I don't feel bad at all for the owners of Triad, they completely got what they deserved. What everyone seems to forget is that a 2 year old boy died, and many people were sickened, by Triad products manufactured in a dirty facility run by arrogant, power and money hungry, self-serving jerks. I know this first hand. What goes around comes around. Their bad karma will still stay with them, no matter if they try to go into business again. They are "tainted" for certain.
OK...I may be a bit naive here - but how can ALCOHOL and IODINE be contaminated by bacteria? After all, aren't they supposed to KILL bacteria?
I could say this story is amazing, but it's not. Cold-hearted bastards like these rule the business world, no matter what size the businesses come in or what merchandise they produce. Like Lisa Holly says, Triad sold contaminated wipes that sickened many people and killed a two-year-old boy. Do the owners of Triad care about these deaths? No way in hell. They only care about their millions, and they must have done a lot of knee-bending and groveling to get that 4 million-dollar penal bond canceled.
Shame on you, CNN for being so shallow. Roland Martin should be brought back immediately!
Fire Obama, I don't like the coment "you folks"
Seems to me its the FDA standards that need revision. How do you recondition something that is already contaminated? Wouldn't you think that there would be strict rules that require certain procedures to avoid any comtaminations especially to so called "sterile products" used in the medical field? Evidently the FDA is too laxed with its guidelines that allow contaminated goods be returned to the manufacturer to be reconditioned. Where is the thinking that they could rework something that is already been proven deadly? It must be extreme if these two STERILE products have been contaminated. And what about the required inspections of these manufacturing industries? Is it possible that the safety of humanity has fallen victim to the almighty dollar? So sad, so damn sad...
Taint my wipe? Wipe my taint?
For all you righties out there - this is WHY government regulation ARE necessary. Now, I won't argue that they CAN go too far, they do. However... when a person's health and safety are concerned...
No right-leaning company is willingly going to say "Let's dispose of millions of dollars of inventory because of one bad item, just put it at the bottom and ship the whole thing."
May the next time something like this happens may it happen to you and yours.
I remember one of these on the news a few months back it was the workers none of whom spoke or understood english All the signs and instructions were in english only If you are going to reduce wages to the point only illegals will work you at least need to translate the instructions in to the workers language for instance the sign in the restrooms simply said wash hands before returning to work not even a picture of washing hands this is the kind of quality they have in a third world country as as it seems china too. that is why triad was so big before the fall. it is all about the good old dollar.
"No right-leaning company is willingly going to say "Let's dispose of millions of dollars of inventory because of one bad item, just put it at the bottom and ship the whole thing."
No Left-leaning company like Apple would stop child labor from building their products in China, taking manufacturing jobs from the US and then pay their CEO 378 million dollars. Oh, I forgot, that's excusable be cause its Apple.
Thus proving my long standing argument that neither the right nor the left is any better or different than the other. They simply desire to keep the people divided on non-issues to prevent us from presenting a unified front against both of them, because then they would lose.